Which is Better: PMP or a Certified Scrum Master (and why)

Choosing between pursuing the Certified ScrumMaster® (CSM®) designation or the Project Management Professional (PMP) certification is a significant decision for anyone seeking to excel in project management and/or agile development. While both designations are esteemed and can propel your career forward, the best choice largely depends on your professional goals, the nature of your projects, and your personal interests. I truly feel the answer is based on distinctive features of both certifications, potential benefits, and considerations to help make an informed decision.

Understanding the Background:

CSM (Certified Scrum Master) is offered by the Scrum Alliance and is specifically designed for those who want to master Scrum, an agile framework. A CSM has the skills to facilitate Scrum practices in teams, propelling effective product delivery. Scrum is particularly popular in software development but has been adopted in various VUCA industries.

PMP (Project Management Professional) is offered by the Project Management Institute (PMI), the PMP is a globally recognized certification that attests to one's knowledge and skills in leading and directing projects. This certification covers a broader scope than the CSM, encompassing various project management methodologies, not just agile or Scrum.

Career Goals & Industry Needs

If you are deeply entrenched in the software industry or are passionate about agile methodologies, CSM can be a better choice. The Scrum framework is commonly adopted in these environments, and a CSM is immediately recognized as someone adept in these practices.

If you're looking at a broad range of industries or want a certification that's recognized universally across different project management methodologies, the PMP is the way to go. It’s versatile and applicable to various sectors like construction, healthcare, finance, and more.

Depth vs. Breadth of Knowledge

The CSM focuses on a specialized set of skills revolving around the Scrum framework. If you want to dive deep into Scrum practices, roles, and ceremonies, this is your pick.

PMP offers a comprehensive curriculum that encompasses various project management processes, knowledge areas, and best practices. It provides a holistic view of project management and has many more moving parts.

Professional Network & Community

Both certifications offer opportunities to join a community of professionals. The Scrum Alliance and PMI both host conferences, workshops, and events that can help in networking and continuous learning. On this they feel somewhat of an equal match.

Time & Financial Commitment

The CSM is generally quicker and less expensive to obtain than the PMP. If time and cost are significant concerns, you might lean towards the CSM. However, remember that the investment in the PMP can provide broader opportunities in the long run.

Continuous Learning

Both certifications require ongoing professional development. CSMs need to renew their certification every two years with SEUs (Scrum Education Units), while PMPs need PDUs (Professional Development Units) every three years.

The Exams

The CSM exam is typically a 50 multiple choice question exam that is time-boxed to 60 min. You must achieve a 74% passing grade over 2 attempts to receive the certification (in addition to taking a class conducted by a Certified Scrum Trainer with the Scrum Alliance). Once achieved however, there are growth tracks that signify a Scrum Master's growth (Advanced Certified Scrum Master and Certified Scrum Professional).

The PMP exam is a rigorous assessment that certifies a candidate's proficiency in project management concepts, practices, and skills. The certification is globally recognized and highly sought after by project managers and employers alike. The exam consists of 180 multiple-choice questions and you have 230 minutes to complete it. The questions cover the three domain areas, People (42%), Process (50%), and Business Environment (8%). There are multiple-choice, multiple response, matching, hotspot, and limited fill-in-the-blank questions. PMI doesn’t publicly disclose a specific passing score, but it's believed to be around 61%. However, the actual percentage can change based on the difficulty of your set of questions.

Before you can take the PMP exam, you need to meet certain educational and professional experience requirements:

  • Educational Background: A secondary degree (high school diploma, associate's degree, or global equivalent) OR a four-year degree (bachelor’s degree or global equivalent).
  • Project Management Experience: Depending on your educational background, you'll need a certain number of hours leading projects.
  • Project Management Education: 35 contact hours of formal project management education (often obtained through PMP prep courses).

The PMP exam is challenging, but with structured preparation, many candidates pass on their first attempt. Understanding the PMBOK, taking numerous practice exams, and actively participating in study groups or forums are keys to success. Once achieved, the PMP certification can open doors to new job opportunities and validate your expertise in project management.

I truly feel the PMP is designed to be much more rigorous because of the breadth and depth of the PMBOK and its application in the industry. The PMI reports about 1 million active PMP holders. The Scrum Alliance does not publish numbers, but it is thought to be in the 400,000-600,000 range.

Related Articles

Want a Raise? Certified Scrum Masters are in Demand, Often Earning Six Figures

During this time of uncertainty and a world-wide pause, it’s a great time to consider a career change. If you’re looking for a high-paying, rewarding career that’s still in demand, consider becoming a Scrum Master. Not only is a Scrum Master a rewarding career where you empower and motivate people...

Read More

Is it Worth it to Become a Certified Scrum Master?

Many are facing the fact that their career progress is stalling in many professions. In my line of work, I get a lot of questions related to the process for switching careers. I've been there too. From 1994-2003, I worked as an operations leadership professional at FedEx Express. To this...

Read More

Does It Matter Where I Take My Certified Scrum Course?

We often get this question: "Does the place where I take a CSM course matter?". In short, yes. There are many reasons professionals seek out certification credentials. No, I don't believe a certification makes someone magical, but I do know that when sorting through piles of resumes, someone that has...

Read More

Which Scrum Master Certification Should I Chose?

You are ready to start your search for a new job as a Scrum Master. It appears that most organizations require you to have a certification. Which Scrum Master certification should you choose? Perhaps you don't even have hands-on experience being a Scrum Master, what then? Landing a Scrum Master...

Read More

Am I Eligible to Become Scrum Master Certified?

The role of a Scrum Master is critical in when using Scrum (or simply an Agile Coach if you are using some other agile process). A Scrum Master acts as a facilitator and coach, helping teams adhere to Agile principles and practices, ensuring effective communication, and resolving impediments that may...

Read More

Should I Pursue a Certified Scrum Master or Certified Scrum Product Owner First?

I get this question frequently, especially from people trying to break into the software development community. Should I pursue the Certified Scrum Master (CSM) or Certified Scrum Product Owner (CSPO) credentials first; either one provides a good baseline on agile / Scrum, but from vastly different angles. As far as...

Read More